Dreamy Vanilla Ice Cream

Whoever coined the term ‘plain vanilla’ has obviously never tasted something made with genuine vanilla beans. If they had, they would know vanilla to be one of the wildest, most exotic, sensual flavors in the world. I mean, it’s the fruit of a tropical orchid, and tastes rich, sweet, fruity and floral all at once. Just because it goes with almost anything you could imagine, from old fashioned fruit desserts to savory entrees, that doesn’t make it plain. Chocolate goes with everything, too, and no one pigeon holes that.

Here’s an excerpt from the Boston Vanilla Bean Company:

Vanilla is considered to be the most labor intensive of all agricultural products. The entire process of vanilla cultivation, pollination and harvesting is done by hand. The cured beans vary in flavor and fragrance depending on where they are grown in the world, the soil, climate and environmental differences as well as the differences in curing processes. Vanilla, like gourmet coffee, is a product of its environment in that its ultimate flavor is affected by the other plants and minerals in the surrounding area.


When you want something sweet to melt over a warm fruit dessert (such as the Maple Sugar, Bourbon, and Brown-Butter Peach Crisp, shown above), look no further than this ice cream. It has a fantastically creamy texture, with the heady, complex (food geek alert!) flavor profile of vanilla bean and just the right amount of sugar to keep it pliable but not be overly sweet.

I usually use the ratio of 1 cup whole milk to 1 1/2 cups heavy cream, but this time I used 1 1/2 cups half and half and 1 cup heavy cream, really just because we like half and half in our breakfast tea better than the milk which would have been leftover. This combination resulted in the smoothest, creamiest, tastiest ice cream I’ve ever had, and will thus be my go-to formula from now on.

Ice cream is dead simple to make, but you do need a few essential tools:

-a wire whisk, for tempering the hot dairy into the egg yolks
-a heat-proof rubber spatula, for stirring the custard
-an instant read thermometer is nice to have, especially if the thought of undercooked eggs gives you the heebie jeebies, but not necessary. Use for gauging the temperature of the custard, which should be between 170º and 175ºF in order to kill any harmful bacteria lurking in the eggs but not curdle the mixture.
-an ice cream maker (natch!) I use the Kitchen Aid stand mixer ice cream maker attachment, which consists of a metal bowl filled with freezy stuff which I keep in my freezer, and a special ‘dasher’ which churns the ice cream. They cost about $75 new. I like that there is already a motor in the mixer, so it is more efficient than buying a separate motor in an electric ice cream maker. If you don’t have a stand mixer, I would recommend this manual ice cream maker from Donvier. This is the model I used for years and years.

Custard-based ice creams do take a bit of planning, as the base needs to chill for at least 4 hours, and preferably overnight, before churning. Putting the base in the freezer for 30 minutes before processing means less time in the ice cream maker having air whipped into it, resulting in a denser, creamier ice cream.

Many recipes will put the fear in you, advising that you cook the custard in a bain marie to prevent it from curdling. This is hogwash. At a certain restaurant which shall remain nameless, all we had was an electric hot-plate style burner. We would crank it up to high and cook the custard quickly. To be safe, keep your flame medium-low, and stir constantly as the custard cooks. If your eggs do begin to form lumps and bumps, remove it from the heat immediately and pour it through a fine mesh sieve and into your cold cream. This should take care of any problems.

Happy ice cream making!

Dreamy Vanilla Ice Cream

Makes about 1 quart

Save the egg whites for making brown-butter financier cakes. They will keep in the fridge for up to a week, or in the freezer for several months.

1 1/2 cups half and half
1/2 vanilla bean, split lengthwise and scraped
1 cup cold heavy cream
4 egg yolks
1/2 cup sugar
pinch salt

In a medium saucepan, heat the half and half with the vanilla bean and scrapings until steaming and small bubbles appear around the sides of the pan. Cover and steep for 30-60 minutes.

Pour the heavy cream into a quart-sized container, such as a mason jar, and set aside. If you have an instant-read thermometer, have it handy.

Place the egg yolks in a medium bowl set on a damp towel to stabilize it. Add the sugar and salt, whisking to combine. Reheat the half and half to a bare scald. Whisking constantly with one hand, pour the hot dairy very slowly into the yolks. (This is called tempering, and prevents the yolks from scrambling.) Pour the mixture back into the pot and set over a medium-low flame. Cook, stirring constantly with a heat-proof rubber spatula, scraping the sides and bottom of the pot, until the custard just begins to ‘stick’ (or form a thickened film) on the bottom of the pot (you may have to tilt the pan to see it), or registers 170º on an instant-read thermometer, 5-10 minutes.

Immediately pour the custard into the container of cold cream, stir to combine, and chill in the fridge for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.

Place the ice cream base in the freezer for 30 minutes to get it really cold. Strain the mixture through a fine mesh sieve, then process in an ice cream maker. ‘Cure’ in the freezer for at least 2 hours for a firmer consistency.

Homemade ice cream is best eaten within the first few days of being made, but will keep for a month or two in the freezer.

Variation: Vanilla Bergamot Ice Cream

This version tastes like a grown-up creamsicle, with hints of earl grey-y muskiness.

Add the finely grated zest of 1 bergamot orange (2 teaspoons lightly packed zest) to steep with the vanilla for 20-30 minutes. After you’ve tempered in the egg yolks and cooked as directed, strain the mixture right into the cold cream. Proceed with the recipe from there.

7 thoughts on “Dreamy Vanilla Ice Cream”

  1. My ice cream making attempts thus far have been disastrous. Even with the new machine.

    Help me, Alanna, you're my only hope!

    I'll give this recipe a shot today or tomorrow (and serve it with bananas brulee). Fingers crossed!

  2. I have the utmost faith in your ice cream making abilities!

    Funny you should mention bananas brulee. We just finished devouring maple-rosemary-banana splits from a book called Herbal Cooking. You lay some nanas in a skillet, pour maple syrup over, tuck a couple rosemary springs underneath, and cook for a couple minutes. Then you transfer the bananas to bowls, and swirl a pat of butter into the syrup left behind in the pan. Pour the sauce over the bananas, and top with scoops of vanilla ice cream, toasted nuts and a few flecks of flaky salt. Oh, yeah!

  3. Ummmm…oh my…this is truly dreamy ice cream. I had a moment of concern when heating the custard that I was getting curdled eggs or that some of the fat was separating out of the cream but in the end the texture turned out beautifully. I added 2 tablespoons of some simple syrup that I cooked my favorite little citrus in and then added those candied citrus pieces at the end of churning. The result is the best ice cream that I've ever made, though I keep saying that the past few ice creams. This one I'll have to make a few more times before kumquats go out of season and your recipe was the perfect vanilla to make a truly dreamy Kumquat Creamsicle Ice Cream. yummmmmm

  4. Oh my, indeed! Kumquat creamsicle ice cream sounds absolutely divine. I never know what to do with those tiny orange buggers… now, I do! Thanks for the brilliant suggestion!

    If your custard began curdling/separating, the flame may have been a bit high. So glad all turned out well, though.

  5. I've been making David Leibovitz's vanilla with the 5 egg yolks, but then saw yours with the 4 (and my favorite macaroons have 4 egg whites). Just churned it up using a scant 1/2 c. of sucanat, and it's wonderful! Thanks!

    1. Ooh, sucanat sounds delicious here – I'll have to try that! So glad you like the ice cream, Rebecca! David L is the god of all things yummy. I love him.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *