This homemade gluten-free biscotti recipe gets a crunchy, buttery crumb from a few gluten-free flours studded with candied hazelnuts. Dip them in chocolate for a classy coffee break treat, or wrap them up for an edible holiday gift. Thanks to Bob's Red Mill for sponsoring this post!
A Lifetime of Biscotti Love
Biscotti hold a special place in my heart. Maybe it's because I grew up in 1990's coffee shop culture, where there was a jar of chocolate covered cookies on every counter. Or maybe it was because my paternal grandmother baked them along with rugelach every year for the holidays. Or maybe it's because they remind me of the Jewish equivalent mandelbrot that my maternal grandfather would share with me after school.
Whatever the reason, biscotti were one of the first "fancy" recipes I learned to bake as a teen from a tiny cookbook called Biscotti containing only a few dozen recipes for the Italian-style slice-and-bake cookies. I loved the process of baking biscotti – mixing the dough, shaping it into logs, baking, slicing, baking again. I always felt so professional when finishing them with chocolate.
I baked biscotti for classmates and teachers. I brought some to a job interview at an Italian restaurant where the chef exclaimed, "Ci sono sempre caldi!" – they're still warm! I baked biscotti at music camp every summer, when I worked in the camp bakery in exchange for attending. And I baked biscotti at bakeries and restaurants where I worked as a young adult.
But this week was my first time braving gluten-free biscotti, and I'm extra excited to share the recipe with you today! I've adapted my favorite wheat biscotti recipe which originally came from the aforementioned book. This post is also part of a virtual cookie swap – scroll down to the bottom to see what my friends baked up!
Ingredients for Gluten-Free Biscotti
- Gluten-free flours form a base that is undetectably gluten-free. Oat flour adds fluff and earthy flavor. Sweet rice flour and tapioca flour make the dough sticky and stretchy, helping it hold together when sliced. Cornstarch adds crunch.
- Eggs beaten with sugar until foamy form the base of this dough.
- Vanilla adds flavor.
- Butter adds moisture and richness. Note that traditional Italian biscotti don't contain any fat, but I vastly prefer the "Americanized" version with lots of delicious butter!
- Baking powder lifts the dough and a good hit of salt sharpens the flavors.
- Candied hazelnuts form addictive crunch and flavor offset by a dip of bittersweet chocolate. You can trade hazelnuts for almonds for more traditional biscotti, or skip the candying step altogether for a more classic biscotti recipe.
How to Make Gluten-Free Biscotti
My gluten-free biscotti recipe uses a couple of less-traditional methods. First, I caramelize the nuts for extra flavor. The original recipe from Biscotti has you cook the nuts in a skillet with butter and sugar until the nuts are coated in a nap of caramel. I used this method here, but when I tried it this time around, my sugar kept crystallizing.
Instead, I make a simple caramel with sugar and a little butter which I quickly use to coat the nuts. When chopped up, this caramel adds a lovely depth of flavor to the biscotti. That said, you can absolutely skip this step. You'll just need to reduce the flour a little to compensate for the lack of caramel. See the note in the recipe.
Once you've prepared the nuts, it's time to make the biscotti dough. Begin by whipping whole eggs with sugar until thick and foamy. Stir in the melted butter and vanilla, then the sifted flour mixture. Unlike wheat doughs, this biscotti dough likes to be worked. So increase the mixer speed and beat the dough for 20 seconds. Stir in the nuts. The dough will be fairly soft at this point, so chill it for an hour or two until firm enough to shape into a log.
Bake the biscotti logs until golden and firm. Let these cool completely otherwise they will be crumble and hard to slice. Use a large, sharp knife to cut the log into slices. Bake the slices until golden.
If using, temper the chocolate as directed. Dip the biscotti into the melted and tempered chocolate, sprinkle with chopped hazelnuts, and enjoy!
Biscotti: American vs. Italian
Most people know that the word biscotti means "twice cooked" referring to the process of baking the logs once, slicing, and baking again. But did you know that biscotti as we know them in the US are actually technically cantucci? In Italy, biscotti (plural) or biscotto (singular) refers to any type of cookie. Think: biscuit in the British sense of the word. Cantucci refers to the type of cookie shown here which hails from Tuscany. But since biscotti are what we call them in the US, I'm going with it!
Traditional Italian biscotti don't contain any fat. Their texture is dry and made to be dipped into espresso or dessert wine. I've tried multiple version for fat-free biscotti and have found that I vastly prefer the Americanized type. These biscotti are best eaten alongside a cozy beverage. But thanks to their buttery nature, you can enjoy them solo too.
Gluten-Free Biscotti Bliss
You'll be hard pressed to guess that these biscotti are gluten-free, thanks to their wheat-like texture from a sturdy flour blend and protein-rich eggs. Bite through the thin chocolate shell to crispy cookie redolent with the flavors of earthy toasted hazelnuts, vanilla, and caramel and you'll be in gluten-free biscotti heaven.
Biscotti, cantucci, Italian slice-and-bake cookies: whatever you call them, when you dunk one of these crunchy, buttery treats in a mug of hot coffee, you'll be calling it delicious!
Gluten-Free Biscotti with Hazelnuts (or Almonds) and Chocolate!
Hazelnuts add an earthy bite to this gluten-free biscotti recipe, but you can use almonds for a more traditional cookie. Or go crazy and try these with pistachios, pumpkin seeds, pecans, or any nut you like!
Though these biscotti are plenty flavorful on their own, you can gild the lily and dunk them in chocolate. I like to temper my chocolate to ensure that it doesn't form any unsightly streaks when it hardens. I've given my preferred method in the recipe, but there are many ways to temper chocolate. You can also skip the tempering step if you prefer.
How to Serve Gluten-Free Biscotti
These gluten-free biscotti with hazelnuts and chocolate pair beautifully with a hot cup of coffee. Enjoy them with an afternoon tea or as an after dinner treat. In Italy, biscotti are traditionally served with a sweet dessert wine such as vin santo.
Give the Gift of Gluten-Free Biscotti
These gluten-free biscotti keep beautifully and make a fine DIY gift. Just pack a bunch into a cookie tin or mason jar tucked into some parchment paper for a sweet holiday present.
*Bojon appétit! For more Bojon Gourmet in your life, follow along on Instagram, Facebook, or Pinterest, purchase my gluten-free cookbook Alternative Baker, or subscribe to receive new posts via email. And if you make this gluten-free biscotti recipe, I’d love to see. Tag your Instagram snaps @The_Bojon_Gourmet and #bojongourmet.*
Gluten-Free Biscotti with Hazelnuts & Chocolate
Print Recipe Pin RecipeIngredients
Hazelnuts:
- 3/4 cup (95 g) toasted hazelnuts (or almonds, pecans, pistachios, pumpkin seeds, or other nuts), plus a handful of finely chopped hazelnuts for sprinkling
- 1 teaspoon unsalted butter
- 3 tablespoons (37 g) granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon corn syrup, golden syrup, or honey
Biscotti:
- 8 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and cooled slightly
- 3/4 cup (150 g) organic granulated sugar
- 2 large eggs
- 1 teaspoon GF vanilla extract
- 1 cup (110 g) Bob’s Red Mill gluten-free oat flour (or try an equal weight of sorghum flour)
- 1 cup (155 g) Bob’s Red Mill sweet rice flour (or 1 to 1 all-purpose gluten-free flour)
- 2 tablespoons (15 g) Bob’s Red Mill tapioca flour
- 2 tablespoons (15 g) Bob’s Red Mill cornstarch
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 1 teaspoon fine sea salt
- 8 ounces (225 g) bittersweet chocolate, coarsely chopped, for dipping
Instructions
Make the hazelnuts:
- In a small, heavy-bottomed saucepan, add enough water to barely cover the bottom of the pan. Add the sugar to the center of the pot, moisten it evenly with the water, and wash any crystals that get on the sides of the pan down into the water. Add the syrup or honey and cover the pot with a lid. Place the pot over medium-high heat and bring to a boil until the sugar has dissolved.
- Have the butter and nuts measured and at the ready, and have a sheet of parchment paper or a baking sheet ready on which to dump the candied nuts.
- Remove the lid from the pot, and, without stirring, boil the syrup until it reaches an amber caramel. (If the mixture begins to crystallize, you can save it by adding more water and beginning the caramelization process again.) Remove the pot from the heat and immediately swirl in the butter, then add the nuts and stir quickly to coat with a heat-proof silicone spatula.
- Dump and scrape the nuts out onto the parchment, and quickly separate the pieces with the spatula as much as possible. When the nuts have cooled, chop them coarsely. Bigger chunks of hazelnut look pretty, but small pieces make the biscotti easier to cut, so choose your own adventure!
Make the biscotti:
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, whip the eggs with 3/4 cup of sugar on medium-high until thick, foamy, and lightened in color, about 3 minutes.
- Meanwhile, sift together the oat flour, sweet rice flour, tapioca flour, cornstarch, baking powder, and salt together into a medium bowl.
- With the mixer on low, add the melted and cooled butter and vanilla. Stir until combined. Add the flour mixture and stir to combine. Increase the mixer to medium and beat for about 20 seconds; this helps activate the sticky qualities of the flour which will help the dough hold together.
- With the mixer on low, stir in the candied chopped hazelnuts. Remove the bowl and give the dough a final fold with a flexible spatula, scraping the bottom of the bowl to make sure the dough is well-combined and the hazelnuts evenly dispersed.
- Cover and chill the dough until firm enough to handle, 1-2 hours. You can chill the dough for up to 2 days at this point, you’ll just want to let it soften a bit before proceeding with the next steps.
- Position two racks in the upper and lower thirds of the oven and preheat to 350ºLine 2 cookie sheets with parchment paper.
- Divide the dough in half and shape each half into a log that’s about 12 inches long, 1 inch high and 2 inches wide. Place longways on the baking sheet (or sheetspaced at least 3 – 4 inches apart. (You can use one sheet for both, but you will need both sheets for the cut cookies.)
- Bake the logs until golden, firm, and cooked through, 25-30 minutes, rotating once or twice. Let the logs cool completely. (At this point, you can wrap and freeze the logs to be baked later if you like.)
- Use a wide metal spatula to remove a log to a cutting board. With a large, sharp chef’s knife, cut the log on a steep diagonal into ½ - ¾-inch thick slices. Place the cookies on the lined baking sheets and repeat with the other log.
- Bake the cookies a second time until dried and golden, about 12-17 minutes, flipping the cookies over halfway through if they are browning more on the underside. Let cool completely.
Temper the chocolate:
- Tempering will prevent the chocolate from forming streaks after it cools. Bring 2 inches of water in a saucepan to a boil. Place the chocolate in a heatproof metal bowl. Remove the pot from the heat and place the bowl over the pot. Stir frequently until the chocolate is completely melted. Remove the bowl from the pot and set it aside while you do other things, stirring the chocolate vigorously every few minutes. The chocolate will cool to room temperature and the stirring keeps it in emulsion. This will take about 30-60 minutes depending on how warm your kitchen is. Note that this method doesn’t work well in high humidity.
- To test the chocolate, smear a little on a piece of parchment paper. It should look matte and mostly set within a minute or two. If the chocolate becomes too firm to work with, place the bowl over the pot of steamy water for a few seconds, stirring constantly, until the chocolate has just barely softened.
- Dip the biscotti in the tempered chocolate and sprinkle with the chopped hazelnuts.
- These biscotti keep well, in an airtight container, for up to 1 week if they last that long.
Notes
Nutrition
This recipe is part of a virtual cookie swap! Check out the delicious cookie recipes my friends are sharing:
- Monster Cookies from Eat The Love
- Classic Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cookies from Snixy Kitchen
- Triple Chocolate Cookies from Hummingbird High
- Honey Walnut Shortbread Cookies from Food Fashion Party
- Paleo Gingerbread Cookies from Foolproof Living
- Snickerdoodle Cookies from Foodness Gracious
Paige Cassandra Flamm says
I haven't had biscotti in ages! These look amazing!
Paige
http://thehappyflammily.com
Alanna says
Thanks Paige!
Sarah @ Snixy Kitchen says
I need to try these. They're so beautiful!! I've never had biscotti and the way you wax poetic about those caramelized hazelnuts has me drooling for them.
Alanna says
Aw! I'll definitely make you batch sometime soon. <3
Florence says
Hi Alanna, your biscotti photos are gorgeous!! I halved the recipe and made them but mine disintegrated when I tried to slice the logs. Not sure what went wrong cos I followed your recipe. Any advice will be appreciated.
Alanna says
I'm really sorry that these gave you trouble! That must have been incredibly frustrating.
I'm happy to help troubleshoot. Could you tell me which flours you used (including which brands) and if you measured by weight or volume? Did you let the logs cool before slicing them or did you cut them warm? Did you use the candied nuts?
Thanks for any extra information!
Aysegul says
You talented you! As always, your photos take my breath away. I love that you shared how to make it ahead as I love prepping my biscotti batter a day before. Such a great recipe. Thanks for sharing.
Cheers!
Alanna says
You're the sweetest. Thanks so much for your help with my posts friend! Appreciate you. <3
Irvin says
These look SO. GOOD. I want a whole batch of them for my morning coffee! (and also another whole batch for my afternoon tea)
Alanna says
Ha! I'm sure more cookies is just what you need ;)
Terri says
Can you sub arrowroot instead of cornstarch?
Alanna says
I'm pretty sure that would work. Will you let me know if you try it?
Trish says
Hi Alanna! I don’t usually comment on recipes I haven’t yet tried, but since I’m away from home, I thought I’d tell you of adapting a regular biscotti recipe to a gf one. My daughter loves the Cooking Light soft spice biscotti recipe and requested it last Christmas. So I substituted Minimalist Baker’s gf flour mix for wheat flour and it turned out really well. She enjoyed it! I hope to try your recipe soon but am a bit thwarted by spending the winter months in a poorly equipped (kitchen-wise!) condo. I miss baking but hope to do the best I can adapting to my surroundings. Where there’s a will there’s a way! Thank you for your excellent work!
Merry Christmas!
Alanna says
Oooh those biscotti sound so good! It's always a thrill when it's easy to convert a recipe to GF, yay! Sorry to hear about your poorly equipped kitchen this winter, but let me know if you brave this recipe! Happy holidays to you as well.
Dolphia Nandi says
is there a way to avoid nuts all together?
Alanna says
Sure! I think you could just leave them off entirely. You might need to decrease the flour a little since there will be less moisture from the lack of caramel. Or you could sub pumpkin seeds!
Marnie says
It’s my first time making biscotti, let alone gluten free biscotti! But your recipe was so easy to follow and the result looks (and tastes) amazing! My logs were slightly crumbly when I started to cut them, I think the hot Australian summer didn’t help, but your troubleshooting tips helped so much, I wrapped them and put them in the fridge and they came out perfect!
Happy holidays!
Alanna says
Thanks so much for trying my recipe and for the note! I'm glad chilling the logs helped them hold together when cut. Hooray!
Sabrina says
have never made biscotti, so thank you for this recipe, love the flavors and texture too with chocolate and hazelnuts!
Alanna says
I'm so glad you liked them!
Lena says
Happy holidays Alanna, love this biscotti recipe...perfect timing for gift giving!
The yummy candied nuts were a breeze...in my excitement to dump them onto the parchment, I spilled some onto the floor...nibbled the rest as there wasn't enough to use in the recipe 😁 I have since made 2 more batches of nuts and 1 of biscotti.
I would like to vary this recipe to make an assortment of biscotti...do you think I could add dried fruit such as cranberries/or apricots and white or dark chocolate without changing the other ingredients?
Alanna says
Aw I'm so glad to hear this!! I'm also curious to try variations (pistachios?!) I think that the dried fruit might absorb moisture in the dough, but then the chocolate might make it spread a little more. I think you could try adding them in without changing the other ratios. If they wind up feeling dry or dense, you might decrease the sweet rice flour by a couple of tablespoons next time. Please let me know what you try!
Jill says
I just made this recipe with pistachio’s and it was amazing! Also I used 1 to 1 GF flour blend instead of all the various flours. Turned out great!
Alanna says
I'm so glad they worked well with the GF blend and pistachios! Thanks a bunch for the note. Feel free to give the recipe a star rating if you like too!
Diane says
These GF beauties tempted me so much I had to give them a go, despite my intimidation. I’m a novice a GF baking and since discovering I have Celiac in my 50s it’s been a bit daunting to relearn how to cook and bake. Since eating healthy is my top priority, learning to cook gf first was essential.
As a perfectionist and one who really struggles with wasted time, ingredients, and money, I have become more and more reluctant to dive into gf baking as too many recipes are complicated for me or end up as disappointments, often requiring multiple ingredients that I won’t use up before they expire. Skilled confectioners such as yourself spend the time required to create gorgeous artisan desserts for those of us without the training, instinct, and drive you must have for this. Then you apply more effort to photograph and blog about them with equal skill for others to enjoy simply to gazing at them or also try the recipe. As for myself, I aspire to make as well as you do. Thank you for what you do and how you have inspired me. I had a couple of thoughts for feedback if you have the time. The dough seemed very wet and sticky, more like a thick batter. I was wondering if maybe I didn’t beat the dough enough to activate the sticky qualities, but it was quite sticky, so I went with it. I had to refrigerate and wait 2 days to bake. I didn’t form into logs first as I didn’t have time. I let the dough sit out for about an hour or more at room temp in a bowl. Maybe that was too long as when I divided it and formed into loaves, the dough was still very sticky and quite soft to handle. When I baked them they spread and flattened a bit. Perhaps next time I will try adding a bit more flour as you recommend. Will any of the 3 be a good choice?
Your cantucci are absolutely beautiful and uniform. Mine came out as a decent first try; and I’m a bit more confident having tried them on my own. Thank you again Alanna for all you do to provide those of us who don’t have the talent, drive, and skill you have at making your craft look so easy and delicious, as well as accessible.
Alanna says
Hi Diane!
Thanks very much for trying my recipe and for the kind words! That means a lot to me.
The dough is definitely very wet and sticky when it's first mixed, but it should firm up quite a bit in the fridge. I do think an hour may have been longer than ideal to soften the dough after chilling. Did you use weight or volume when you measured the flour? If you used volume, it's possible that you measured the flours a little light or something and that the dough does need a bit more flour added. In any case, I'm so glad you liked these and that they made GF baking feel a little more accessible! Let me know if there are any goods your itching to bake or cook and I can try to point you toward a good recipe or two. :)
SJ says
I made these using 4 tablespoons of olive oil instead of the butter to cater to a dairy free individual. I did not caramelize the nuts and forgot to take out the 2T of mochiko. They were delicious! They were a bit more tender (maybe my second bake wasn't long enough) than I'm used to for biscotti but I made so many changes/mess ups that it could be due to any one of those reasons (or all). Above mentioned individual is grain free (which I didn't realize) so that means two logs of biscotti for meeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!
Alanna says
Aw that was sweet of you to accommodate your guest! What a shame they couldn't eat them after all. I love the idea to use olive oil here, I'll have to try that. Thanks a bunch for making my recipe and for the sweet note!
Makos says
One of my friends was diagnosed gluten intolerant recently. He loves a recipe for Cretan almond biscotti I make very often, but they're made with regular flour. I think these look like the perfect treat for him now :)
Alanna says
Oooh I've never heard of that type of biscotti before. You could definitely use almonds here though. Please let me know if you give them a go!
Devida D'angelo says
Best gf biscotti I've made and I've made many! Great flavor and texture. Grazie!
Alanna says
That is awesome to hear!! I'm so glad you like them. If you feel inspired to leave a star rating please do! :)
Morgan says
Hi! I don't have a paddle attachment for a hand mixer - only a standard wisk for a hand mixer. Do you think this will work or do you have any other advise for how to make without a stand mixer?! Also - do you think i could swap butter for coconut oil?
Alanna says
You could certainly try whisking the eggs by hand until they're thick and foamy, it will just take a bit of muscle. I *think* coconut oil should work fine in place of the butter. Please let me know what you try!
Rajvi says
Hey, Can we substitute eggs with anything else? Thank you!
Alanna says
That's a great question. Eggs are tricky to substitute, especially here where they're whipped with sugar to help with the texture. Some common ones are aquafaba, flax egg, applesauce, sour cream, pumpkin, Just Egg, and egg replacer. Let me know if you experiment and I'll do the same!
Is says
Hi. Can I use regular flour?
If so, how much?
Alanna says
You can! Here's a similar recipe that uses wheat flour. I only needed 2 cups when I made the same formula before, so I think 2 cups of AP flour should work here as well. Please let me know if you try it!
April says
Thank you for sharing such a great recipe. I cannot try to make these but since I can't tolerate rice, can I sub it with more oat flour? I have gone through every single bag of GF blend that I could find in the supermarket and they all have rice flour in them so I don't think they will work out for me. Thanks in advance.
Alanna says
Ah that's so tough. Have you tried cassava flour? It's similarly sticky and starchy as sweet rice flour. You can certainly try using more oat flour, but it may be more crumbly or dense. You might swap in a couple more tablespoons of the starches to give the dough more hold and lightness. Please let me know what you try! I always recommend making a half batch when tweaking a recipe, just in case you don't love how it turns out the first time. :)
Gia says
These are gorgeous!! I grew up enjoying traditional rustic Italian biscotti- walnut with anise, and pure vanilla ones. Any specific suggestion as to how I could use your recipe to recreate both of my childhood favorites which are laced with so much nostalgia and love? Your blog is beautiful…
Alanna says
Aw thank you Gia, I really appreciate that! I have a soft spot for anise biscotti too - I think my bubba used to make those when I was very little.
I looked up an anise biscotti recipe in my Biscotti cookbook and here's what I'd try, based on the original recipe:
Omit the candied hazelnuts and use toasted walnuts instead. Omit the vanilla and the melted chocolate. Place 1 tablespoon anise seed and 2 tablespoons Sambuca liqueur or Pernod in a small saucepan. Set over low heat and warm until steamy, 2-3 minutes. Set aside to cool. Add this mixture along with the melted butter.
For the vanilla biscotti, omit the hazelnuts and chocolate, and increase the vanilla to 2 or 3 teaspoons. Decrease the sweet rice flour by 1 tablespoon.
Please let me know if you try either of these! Buon appetito. :)
David says
Delicious! I wanted a recipe as close to wheat-based as possible. This is it! Hazelnuts and chocolate…GREAT combination, especially with a cappuccino:). I do wish I had read to the bottom of the “Troubleshooting” tips first. I was in a hurry to finish the recipe and cut the logs before the middles were completely cool, so I ended up with some pieces and even crumbles. But the taste is perfect! Next time I think I’ll make the logs one day, then refrigerate over night before cutting up for the second bake. Thank you so much for fulfilling this gluten-free biscotti-lover’s quest for the “holy grail” of coffee accompaniments…although I think I will be eating them more often than I’m drinking coffee!
Alanna says
I'm so glad you love the recipe! Hard to beat homemade biscotti and a cappuccino, yum. Baking the logs ahead of time should make them easier to cut. Please let me know how it goes if/when you make them again!
Eugenie says
The texture of these are absolutely perfect! I used your vanilla version as instructed in a reply and probably would add even 4 or 5 tsp of vanilla next time. One question- I cannot tolerate refined sugar so used coconut sugar, but it discolored the biscotti. (Not that I minded much, as they were so delicious!!). I’d like to use liquid stevia if possible or another alternative sweetener that would keep these ‘pure style’. Any suggestions? Can’t wait to make these again and again!! They will replace my long lost loves, which were always my grandmothers biscotti…I have a coconut oil and clear vanilla extract ‘sprinkles biscotti’ version in mind as well for this and hope it will work!
Alanna Taylor-Tobin says
I'm so glad you loved these Eugenie, and that they worked with the coconut sugar! I hear you about the color. Maple sugar tends to bake up lighter, though it's not cheap. I haven't experimented much with sweeteners like stevia and monkfruit because I don't love the flavor. If you use stevia, you'll need to make up for the moisture lost from the sugar, maybe adding a little milk or plant milk? It may take some experimentation. You could also try using half maple or coconut sugar and half stevia to start, and decrease from there. Please let me know what you experiment with!
Solange says
Sadly, I can’t have refined sugar. What other natural sweetener could I use here and how much of it? I use coconut sugar often but I imagine it would discolor the biscotti. These are beautiful- I’m planning on playing and making many variations of them using this recipe as my ‘home’.
Alanna Taylor-Tobin says
Hi Solange!
Maple sugar would be my suggestion, although it isn't cheap. But the flavor is divine and it's fairly light in color too! Your best bet would be to substitute it by weight as maple and coconut sugar weigh lighter than granulated. For what it's worth, I think coconut sugar would taste lovely here and I wouldn't mind a little molasses color in the biscotti. Please let me know what you try!
Do skip caramelizing the hazelnuts though, as that will only work with granulated sugar!
Gia says
Gia here, just returning to share that I made the vanilla version you so kindly suggested and actually used coconut sugar (also Earth Balance sticks, so took down the salt a touch, etc). The biscotti were divine; I could not stop eating them! I placed the coconut sugar in a high speed blender to make it finer, then actually added the rest of the dry ingredients as well, hoping to make a finer dry ingredient mix as sometimes gluten free anything can taste grainy. I’m not sure if this helped, but they certainly were perfect in every way. The coconut sugar did create a darker hue but the result almost looked like they were toasted already, so I didn’t mind at all. They were even more delicious soft before toasting; I sliced a big chunk off the log to devour a hot, doughy, Madagascar bourbon vanilla infused spongy end. I’ll be trying the anise version next and just want to thank you for returning a treasured, lost recipe to me I haven’t been able to find since changing the way I bake.
Alanna Taylor-Tobin says
That's so smart to grind the coconut sugar and flours to a finer consistency - brilliant! I'm so glad the vanilla version worked well. I also like the spongy once-baked dough just as well as the crunchy finished cookies.
Please let me know if you try the anise version!
Honore says
Happy Spring! I’m planning on making a grain free version of pizza rustica this weekend and was checking out your anise biscotti suggestion. I haven’t made biscotti for so long; i feared they just wouldn’t be the same now that I’m practicing a dairy/gluten/refined sugar free way of life. I remember using both vanilla extract and anise extract (or anise oil but a lot less than the extract). I’m wondering if I could try a tsp or two of vanilla extract and a tsp or less anise extract here, in lieu of the Sambuca and anise seed concoction. Also, if I use walnuts, should they be toasted or can they remain raw before adding?
Alanna Taylor-Tobin says
Happy spring to you too! Mmm that all sounds delicious. I think toasted walnuts would have a nicer flavor and crunch, but either will work! Anise extract would totally work. Let me know how much you end up going with!
ooshma says
Hello Hello, I was wondering if it is possible to substitute the eggs for chia eggs maybe?
Alanna Taylor-Tobin says
Hello! Hm, that's a great question. I worry that chia eggs might make the dough gummy, and you'd have to use a different mixing method because here the eggs and sugar are whipped together.
This recipe uses water + egg replacer; I wonder if that could work? That recipe uses xanthan gum to hold the dough together, so these might turn out more crumbly. You would want to use softened butter, beat that with the sugar, then beat in the egg replacer, then stir in the dry ingredients. Aquafaba could be another egg sub to try.
I'd recommend trying a half batch in case you don't love the outcome! Please come back let us all know if you experiment :)
Christina says
I cannot do even half of the sugar, even low-glycemic maple or coconut. I’ve experimented with many King Arthur biscotti recipes before finding yours and honestly can only tolerate a tablespoon or two of sugar overall, as vanilla has sugar in it as well and I’m heavy handed with the bourbon vanilla extract;) Would I be able to pull these off by adding in more fat in lieu of adding plant milk if I drastically cut the sugar? I realize baking is all chemistry and hate to change course but must due to severe allergies and health issues. Thank you!
Alanna Taylor-Tobin says
Hi Christina,
Oh how I feel your pain, lots of food issues over here too! So sorry you're suffering :(
Absolutely go ahead and experiment with this recipe. I'm wondering if you could add extra egg as well as fat to make up for the sugar too?
Please let me know what you try!